Prophylaxis
Ask what your opponent wants to do next, and stop it before you start your own plan: four master games show how.
Try Interactive LessonIntroduction
Lesson Content
Karpov – Spassky, Candidates semifinal 1974, game 11. White is to move and has several useful moves. Ask the question first: what does Black want to do next? Look at the pawn on c7. It stands on a file where White has no pawn, in front of White's rook on c1, and the pawns beside it have already moved ahead. As long as it stays there, it is a target. So Black wants to push it to c5. That push attacks d4, gives Black's pieces more room and gets rid of the weak pawn. If it were Black's move here, the push would level the game.
Black is ready to push the c-pawn two squares. Find the quiet pawn move that makes that push lose a pawn.
b4 puts a second white pawn on guard over c5. If Black pushes the c-pawn now, White takes it with the d-pawn, and after the recapture the knight on c3 jumps to e4 and hits the queen and the bishop on f6. Black's pawn on d5 cannot take that knight, because then White's queen takes the queen on d6. So the push costs Black the pawn on c5. Spassky gave up the idea and put his own pawn on b5, and his c-pawn never got to c5.
The same game five moves later. This is what the quiet move bought. Black's c-pawn is stuck on c6, behind its neighbours. The square in front of it, c5, belongs to White: no black pawn can attack it, and a white knight sits there and looks at a6, b7 and e6. Black's bishop has gone back from b7 to c8, because on b7 its own pawns on a6 and c6 blocked it. White won nothing by force. He took away the one push that made Black's position work, and after that his own plan was easy to find.
Karpov – Westerinen, Nice Olympiad 1974. The question works for pieces as well as for pawns. Black's last move put a knight on a5, at the edge of the board. A piece on a poor square is on its way to a better one, so ask where it is going. What does Black want to do next?
Karpov – Uhlmann, Madrid 1973. Black's a-pawn wants to take one more step and chase your knight from b3, and then the queen takes on b2. Stop the pawn with a move that also wins a square for your own pieces.
a4 blocks the black pawn on a5. The knight keeps its place on b3 and keeps the b-file closed, so Black's queen cannot take on b2. The move is more than a parry: the pawn on a4 now guards b5, and two moves later Karpov's bishop settled there, protected by the pawn, where no black pawn could drive it away. Compare a move that only waits, such as a queen move along the d-file. Black pushes the a-pawn, the knight has to leave b3, and White's small advantage is gone. Good prophylaxis stops the opponent's idea and improves your own position with the same move.
Petrosian – Unzicker, Hamburg 1960. White has both rooks on the only open file, and Black's queen and rook are tied to the defence of the pawn on a5. That is not yet enough to win. White needs a second target, and it can only be on the kingside, where his pawns will have to advance and open lines. Open lines near g1 would be open for Black's pieces too. So Petrosian asked the question about a plan that did not exist yet: what will Black do when the kingside opens? Then he walked his king from g1 to f1, e1, d1, c1 and b1 before he opened anything. It cost five king moves and nothing else, because Black had no active plan and did little more than move his own king between g8 and h7.
The same game twelve moves later. Your king is safe on the other side of the board. Now open the files in front of Black's king.
g4 is the move the king walk was made for. After hxg4, ♕︎xg4 the h-pawn is ready to go to h5, and the files in front of Black's king come open while White's own king stands far away on b1. Black's queen and rook are still on the queenside, too far away to help. Petrosian broke through on the kingside and won the game.
Back to Karpov – Spassky, two moves after the position with the knight on c5. Black has found an idea after all. His queen on d6 and his bishop on c7 are lined up against g3, the other bishop can come to h3, and the f-pawn is ready to run to f4 and open the king's position. This is no longer a plan for later. It is an attack that arrives in two or three moves. What should White do?
Key Takeaways
- Before every quiet move, ask: what does my opponent want to do next?
- Find the pawn break that would free the opponent's game, then make it impossible or make it cost material.
- A piece on a poor square is heading for a better one. Take that square away and the piece stays poor.
- Prefer the move that stops the idea and also improves your own position to a move that only waits.
- Move your king to safety before you open the side of the board it stands on, not after.
- Prophylaxis works against plans. Against an attack that is already there, answer with a threat of your own.
Now play it through
Step through every move on a real board, try the wrong ones, and ask Knighty why they fail.
Related Lessons
Summary
Ready to Practice?
Next in this course
Positional Sacrifices
Take this lesson with you
Free account requiredWith every variation — opens in Lichess & ChessBase











